Controlling sibling

My dad died in April. I cared for dad and mum until dad died which was so stressful I ended up in hospital. He was my mum’s carer who has Alzheimer’s, but she was very fit, lived at home, saw friends, went to church and saw us, her family, who moved to Scotland to be with near them nearly 20 years ago.

After dad died, my brother helped himself to a large financial sum, circumventing the will and then more in padded out “expenses” for which there were never any receipts. Thousands of pounds have gone missing.

He took over everything: made himself primary contact for all agencies who ignored my PoA. He diverted my parents administration to his house in England.

He sent manipulative and slanderous emails copying social services painting me as uncaring and self-serving although I have not touched a penny of their money and often paid for things for mum myself.

During this time the stress became so unbearable I went missing for a week from my family and I had my first suicidal thoughts in the summer.

A few weeks later, with 24 hours notice (on my birthday) he moved mum away from the live-in carer arrangements which he had sabotaged to England, away from us and her community, friends & church of 30+ years. He locked her in a care home and put a deprivation of liberty order on her. She had always begged us not to put her in a care home and she always wanted to stay in Scotland.

Meanwhile he sent more vicious emails me saying how I didn’t care about Mum whereas I saw her mum every day, took her out on trips took her to my home took her to help appointments.
I have never responded to any of his emails in fact we asked him not to contact us which he ignored. Eventually we had to block him on all channels but he still persists.

Now he has her where he can control her and all her assets.

He took away her hearing aids and she doesn’t hear her mobile phone now so we can’t call her.

The care home staff were so horrific the first day that I called to say how I concerned I was when I spoke to mum in profound distress the night she was put there, that that I have only called there a few times & always via my husband to speak to her. They could not have been more unhelpful, unkind or dismissive. Their message was: you don’t count (because you don’t pay). You have no say and we are not interested what you think about your mother’s interests. I had just tried to ask them if she could go out for a walk and what the circumstances there were.
Half the time we have called their phone system hasn’t worked.

Mum has a four bedroom house here where her son and his family used to stay when they visited my parents. When she was in Scotland she was getting partial state support. In England he makes her pay for everything herself. We have nowhere to stay in Manchester and mum’s home is Scotland! It is also a 5 hour journey trip away. I could not face going there alone anyway now because of my mental health and risk of seeing him or even navigating the care home and staff and we shouldn’t have to because Mum should be here in familiar surroundings with the friends and family she has always seen. My husband says it would also be very bad for my mental health and he is right.

I am a shell of the person I used to be because of her son’s actions.

We can never see Mum but we know her son and daughter-in-law listen into our phone calls. We have no privacy. They delete or do not show her the messages I sent with photos because I know she would have called me back and they control her phone.

In desperation I started to send Mum cards. We rang to see if she got them fearing they have been censored. A staff member confirmed she had but they were not on display which is not like mum at all so they must have been put away by others.

Me and my family have been completely pushed out of every aspect of mum’s life.

Even though we both have power of attorney, I effectively don’t have it. I get zero information from the care home. They make empty promises. When I asked if I could visit Mum because we suspected he had imposed some ban and asked if we could take her out the way he does, the director side stepped the latter question.

He has utterly destroyed my mental health. I was suicidal while caring for both my parents at the start of the year and again since the emails, manipulation & ambushing started up again in August & mum’s abduction.

Local social services have been no help. They just see mum as someone else’s problem now. They recommended a mediation service which didn’t reply until I got the MSP involved.

Ditto OPG. When pushed by MSP, OPG replied saying put it in a form but by then my mental health was so bad

I just had to focus on getting better.
We went to the police about the stolen money but they said if he has power of attorney he can do what he wants or get a lawyer.

He is aggressive frightening, brazen, a bulldozer & very manipulative. He will tell Mum things about me to hurt her and make me listen to them because he knows mum can’t do anything and will forget but because he knows it upsets me to hear that. He uses his elderly and vulnerable mother as a pawn to hurt me. He keeps me on the line because he knows I am desperate to speak to Mum. He disparages me in writing & on the phone in front of mum, calls me autistic. He loves torturing me like this. I think it is the part of the whole thing where he gets most pleasure.

Once I was in a cafe and had to move when someone his build with an English accent and a belligerent tone sat down next to me. It was like a trigger of trauma.

We went to the police again in Oct when he kept ambushing my calls to Mum or hers to me (which I later realised he had set up, but not on video obviously) this way and I was in a terrible state. They said in Scotland coercive and controlling behaviour only applies to a domestic partner. When he did it again after Xmas and I was profoundly distressed again we called the English police because there it applies to family members. We found out the care home had told lies to the police about me that I never call and painted me as uncaring. The police obviously weren’t interested in someone who purportedly doesn’t care about their mum and said they only look at cases where the controller lives with the person being controlled and only relates to domestic abuse.

We previously looked into getting a lawyer but it was too expensive. My husband has a good salary but it all goes on mortgage and bills. We tried the mediator that social services had recommended but they wouldn’t help.
We now have found another mediator but the whole point of that was to try and see mum Christmas but there wasn’t time and she didn’t come home anyway.

Today after being dismissed by Manchester police and painted as indifferent by the “care” home. I had an episode where I just froze, I couldn’t move, my body locked up for 4 hours and my husband had to get an ambulance. I went to pieces again, pure fear when the paramedics walked in because they were both tall males & one of them had his build and facial characteristics. I knew they were there to help but it was like another part of me didn’t know.

I’m at my wits end and my body is shutting down which is exactly what he wants. If running me down and ensuring I am dismissed by the authorities doesn’t shut me up I think he is driving me to act in such a way that I will be me sectioned or locked up. That is what it feels like. I am a nature lover who picks up litter every day. I have several degrees and speak four languages. He dropped out of university as an alcoholic before blagging his way into a good job.

Two days ago when he ambushed my call to mum again, toyed with me and manipulated me all the while keeping me on the line in the hope of speaking to Mum, graphic violent scenarios against him & his wife played out in my head. That’s when we called the Mcr police but no one helps.
It is as though mum is in limbo, not dead but not alive - not from her illness but from the way she has been cut off from us. I can’t grieve for her properly because she’s still alive but we have been prevented from having the relationship we had or any relationship by him. The situation is destroying me and affecting my family terribly. I can’t let go and move on but I can’t tolerate the situation I’m in. Since a small child he engineered situations to where he could enjoy seeing me in pain. I think his main motivation is her assets though because my parents were well off. He probably won’t bother trying to get me me written out of the will because the way he is going he will probably have spent it all. I’m dealing with a monster as greedy as it is sadistic and as cunning.
Does anyone know of any forum specifically for people with controlling, manipulative & intimidating siblings/relatives? I know it is common.

Every time I tried to get help from anywhere official everything gets worse.

Hello Dialex

I’m part of the Online Community team and I can see that you are new to the community. I’m so sorry to hear about your dad, and that your mum is so unwell. It sounds like a really difficult situation.

I’m going to suggest a few resources that may be a support to you. There is lots of support out there, and I would really encourage you to reach out and speak to someone about how you are feeling.

  • If these thoughts of suicide become overwhelming, please call 999 or contact your GP for an emergency appointment immediately.

  • You can call 111 and choose the mental health option to speak to a trained mental health professional (England, Scotland and Wales only)

  • Samaritans are available 24/7 to talk about anything that you are worried about in confidence. You can call them on 116 123.

  • Shout are contactable by text, 24/7. You can text REMEDY to 85258 and talk to them about anything.

  • You can also find your local NHS urgent mental health helpline.

  • You can also make an appointment with your GP and ask to be referred to counselling or other support services in your area.

  • Alzheimer’s Society offer advice and support to people affected by dementia. You can call their Dementia Support Line free on 0333 150 3456.

  • The Citizens Advice Bureau may be able to offer some advice at https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/

  • Advice Now offers some free support with legal issues https://www.advicenow.org.uk/

  • Mind offers free mental health advice and support at Home - Mind

I hope you can find the support you are looking for, and access more support if you need it.

Take care, Rhi

Thank you for your advice.

Hello Dialex,

I have only just seen your post.

This is horrendous! I am so sorry you are going through this.

I can’t believe that your POA was overlooked, when the whole point of it is for you to be able to deal with affairs legally when your parents could no longer do this.

My neighbour had a similar situation - her brother pushed her out of everything, even though she was the only one out of her siblings who looked after both parents who had dementia. He actually persuaded their father to cut her out of his will, which she thinks was done when he was at a fairly progressive stage of the illness.

I really hope that mentally you are now in a bit of a better place. :green_heart:

Thank you for your message and I am so sorry that your neighbour experienced this. It is absolutely shocking that somebody at an advanced state of illness can still be deemed as having capacity to change the will against the caregiver. I should check that he hasn’t already done that.

For all the evil that he has done and all that I don’t think he has any right to any more money than he has already stolen and for all that I am getting nothing looking after mum and for all that he will I am sure continue to abuse me and probably fight me legally for anything he can and for all that I think Mum would probably quite readily disinherit him, and for all that I wish every day that he and his wife were dead for all the evil they have created and the hurt and damage have caused, it has not crossed my mind to attempt to disinherit him.

Through great good fortune and mum still being able to express her own wishes, she is now with me. He refused to give Mum her medication until she had said to him something he well knew, that she wanted to stay in Scotland. And yet even though she said this clearly with many witnesses he would not accept it and tried to abduct her again with manipulation and coercion that was sickening to witness like a stranger giving sweets to a child to get them into a car. We had to call the police to get him off the property.

I really struggle to understand the evil in people that makes them be so cruel and so greedy. He has done and it’s still doing so many wicked things it is still sickening to think of it.

I tried to think why he would do that, why he would take her hearing aids, why he would stop full-time professional staff helping her with them, why he would steal from her which we have found out is the case hundreds, if not thousands of pounds while she was in the care home. Her savings account seems to have disappeared. And we don’t know what has happened to the income streams of dads that should be going to her but which may now be going to him. We don’t know because he took the documents with all of dads financial instructions in the event of his death and mum’s death and deleted them off the computer so that I could not read them.

Then there is the campaign of lies and false narrative to all of mum’s friends and the authorities and the rest of our family. He has convinced himself though that he is right but sometimes I see for him it is all s game because I see the way he talks for his camera and I see that he knows that I know he is lying because he just wants to win. All the time he just wants to win.

But that is so sick. Every time I have heard him speak to Mum he is saying things that will hurt her or he is brow beating her or manipulating or coercing her. Where is the winning the competition in that? So why does he do that? I think he’s not able to control himself properly and maybe that is what makes him so controlling of others.

I wonder what else could motivate him. In my experience people who behave very badly fundamentally do so out of fear. Mum suggested his obsession with control ( my disempowerment is part of that) is because he doesn’t actually feel very confident. And yet you wouldn’t think it because he bigs himself up so much and talks so plausibly and so earnestly to anyone who will listen about how everything he is doing is in Mum’s interests and he is the grown up the competent one the organiser and yet everything has touched is an organisational disaster except what is in his own interests. He would look sorrowful to anyone he talks toabout his sister who “clearly has mental health problems” and “needs help” is apparently “autistic” and he is “sure” has “undiagnosed Asperger’s since childhood” or so he bent mum’s ear when he last spoke to her on the phone. Mum was horrified and I was white with shock that he would say that about me to someone with Alzheimers who wasn’t going to remember. It wasn’t to mum really it was to me. Because he has such a strategist he knows I wouldn’t leave mum alone to speak to him in case he tried to manipulate her into so he uses the opportunity to wound.

I think what he hates about me is that I have witnessed what he has done. I have witnessed the very worst of him, his obsession with control, coercion, manipulation, his false narrative, lies and slander, his strategic alliances on the back of those lies, his abuse of mum and disregard for her wishes, his isolation of her from her family, friends and everything familiar, his theft, his disempowerment, intimidation and harassment of me to make me afraid. He was very successful in that, so much so that I’ve only for the first time being able to use mum’s bank card to pay for one small thing despite that she has been living with us for nearly a month.
So when you have done so much evil but you can’t acknowledge it in yourself and yet at some level you do know, perhaps you want to punish the person who does know, who is the witness to that. Perhaps you want to discredit and obliterate them because that is the only way I can explain it. That and greed.

Mum has told three doctors the police social services and Alzheimer’s UK that she is happy, that she’s really well taken care of, that she loves being with us, that I look after her like nobody else and she wants to stay here and we have many many recordings of the same. In terms of her welfare I think we are fine albeit she is not as well as she was before she went in the care home but she is regaining that.

The lies from the care home and the cover-up, which was care UK, have been absolutely horrific. Mum had some kind of trauma to her foot and toe since she went into that care home and according to the podiatrist we saw this week it has caused a fungal nail infection which has damaged the toe and is now permanent as a result. But Care UK say they were unaware of that and it must what happened since you got out.
Mum cam
e back on antidepressants and when I took that up with the care home, they hadn’t bothered to tell me of course but then they never told me anything - they said they didn’t have to - they blamed me. They said mum was fine until I started writing cards to her in December. I started writing cards because I wasn’t able to get hold of her easily by phone. By the same token they admitted they hadn’t given her all the cards but had given them to the son because he seems to give an instructions for them to do that, so she never got all of them. In my last card I was so sure they were being censored that I resorted to telling Mum to hide the card under her mattress and I would tell her in the next card where she was keeping them. Just so I could keep a connection with her just so that she knew she was loved and not forgotten and that we weren’t responsible for incarcerating her in another country hours from home and away from everything familiar. But she wasn’t even getting them. They were being censored before she got them not taken away afterwards. The extent to which he cut us off from her was extraordinary.

But he is still using the family, social services anything he can to still try and attack me, mostly it seems by spreading a false narrative about me. What I find so dispiriting is that he is not in being investigated by social services. I was so concerned about his behaviour in August last year I wrote to them in detail about what he had been doing but they did nothing for a month and then he abducted her. I found out afterwards they should have done an investigation. Other people told me. They never acknowledged this nor apologised and so far they don’t seem to have done anything again despite my contacting them concerned about another abduction attempt and the theft that we have now seen in black and white.

There is a real failing in the authorities here in the police, in the law, in social services that this kind of abuse and harassment can go unpunished, unaddressed, not even acknowledged. And there is a feeling on a more societal level in that this kind of abuse seems to be incredibly common and is not talked about nationally, there is no national conversation in the way there was for e.g. #metoo or any of the other national scandals

Family abuse of vulnerable relatives and other POA holders seems to me incredibly common and the tactics used are brutal. It is quite possible to manipulate, lie coerce, harass, intimidate and abuse over a distance and yet nobody seems to believe this.

I just look after Mum. Notwithstanding her illness I love spending time with her and this is something that he will never have. That is not where this should stop. Unpaid carers are at high risk of suicide. I know a carer who committed suicide. We save so much money. The job is hard. And at the same time many carers are being abused by controlling siblings and what I find as depressing as that abuse is the isolation and the silence around that both in my particular case and on a national level.

Hello Dialex,

You sound like an amazing daughter who is doing what she can considering the circumstances.

Your moral compass is definitely in the right place, and your brother’s definitely is not.

Will you get legal assistance with everything?